Former Marine Indicted Over Chokehold Death of Jordan Neely on New York Subway
Guardian UK
Neely's death at the hands of Daniel Penny was ruled a homicide, according to the medical examiner. (photo: AP)
New York grand jury indicts Daniel Penny, sources say, over death of Neely, a well-known subway performer, in May
Penny, 24, was captured in videos recorded by bystanders putting Neely in a chokehold on 1 May while they rode on an F train in Manhattan.
The killing drew national attention and sparked protests in May by those angered by the police’s delay in arresting Penny, who is white, for killing Neely, a Black man.
At an initial court appearance last month, Penny was charged with one count of second-degree manslaughter.
The charge or charges in the grand jury indictment will not be unsealed until Penny appears in court at a later date, a person familiar with the case said, speaking on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak on the record.
Neither the district attorney’s office nor Penny’s defense lawyer immediately responded to requests for comment. Grand jury proceedings are secret, but New York’s mayor, Eric Adams, acknowledged the indictment in a statement, saying “a trial and justice can move forward”.
Penny was arraigned on 12 May at the Manhattan criminal court on a charge of second-degree manslaughter, a felony crime that carries a maximum sentence of 15 years in prison. Judge Kevin McGrath released Penny on a $100,000 bond and ordered him to surrender his passport and to return to court on 17 July.
As required to bring an indictment on felony charges in New York, prosecutors from the office of the Manhattan district attorney, Alvin Bragg, presented evidence to a grand jury of 23 Manhattan residents.
Most defendants do not testify to a grand jury themselves, but the New York Times reported that Penny planned to appear before the grand jury under oath.
Neely, a 30-year-old former Michael Jackson impersonator who struggled with mental illness, had been shouting about how hungry he was and that he was willing to return to jail or die, according to eyewitnesses.
Penny has said he acted to defend himself and other passengers on the train, and did not intend to kill Neely. Witnesses have said Neely did not physically threaten or attack anyone before Penny grabbed him.
Penny was questioned by police that day but would not be arrested and make an initial court appearance until 11 days after the killing.
His actions have been defended by conservative broadcasters and Republican politicians around the country, and a legal defense fund for him has drawn nearly $3m in donations.
In an interview with the New York Post, Penny defended his own actions and denied that he was acting as a vigilante, insisting: “I’m not a white supremacist … I’m a normal guy.
“I’m deeply saddened by the loss of life,” he said during that interview. “It’s tragic what happened to him. Hopefully we can change the system that’s so desperately failed us.”
Neely’s family criticized Penny for offering neither “an apology nor an expression of regret” and that his statements about Neely’s record amounted to “a character assassination”.
The killing renewed debate about gaps in the city’s support systems for homeless and mentally ill New Yorkers.
Neely was well known to some people who work with homeless New Yorkers and had been in and out of city shelters over the years. Neely was in a cycle of mental health crises, arrests and hospitalization that would continue until his death. Over the last decade, police reportedly arrested Neely 42 times for infractions such as drug use and fare beating, and responded to another 43 calls for an “aided case”, meaning someone reported that Neely was sick, injured or mentally ill.
Earlier this year, Adams said he intended to reduce the number of homeless people seeking shelter in the subway by increasing police patrols and expanding outreach to mentally ill people, including the use of involuntary hospitalizations.
